KnoxCall vs AWS Secrets Manager

While AWS Secrets Manager excels within the AWS ecosystem, KnoxCall provides a vendor-neutral solution with built-in API proxying—no Lambda functions or API Gateway required.

Get Started Free View All Comparisons

KnoxCall Advantages

Vendor-neutral—works with any cloud or on-premise
Built-in API proxy—no Lambda or API Gateway needed
Flat, predictable pricing vs usage-based billing
Integrated analytics and monitoring dashboard
Visual workflow builder included
Single platform for routing + secrets

AWS Secrets Manager Advantages

Deep AWS service integration
Native RDS credential rotation
Pay-per-use for low-volume workloads
Familiar for AWS-heavy teams
AWS IAM integration

Feature Comparison

Core Functionality

Feature	KnoxCall	AWS SM
API Proxying & Routing Route and transform API requests	✓	✗ Requires API Gateway + Lambda
Secrets Storage Secure credential storage	✓	✓
OAuth2 Token Management Automatic token refresh	✓	✗ Manual implementation required
Secret Versioning Track secret history	✓	✓
Automatic Rotation Rotate credentials automatically	~ OAuth2 tokens auto-refresh	✓ For supported AWS services

Pricing & Billing

Feature	KnoxCall	AWS SM
Pricing Model How you pay for the service	Flat monthly	Per-secret + per-call
Predictable Costs Know your bill in advance	✓	~ Can spike with usage
Included API Calls API calls in base price	✓ Up to 1M on Pro plan	✗ $0.05 per 10K calls

Multi-Cloud & Portability

Feature	KnoxCall	AWS SM
Cloud Agnostic Works across cloud providers	✓	✗ AWS-only
On-premise Support Use with on-premise systems	✓	~ Limited via VPC endpoints
No Vendor Lock-in Easy to migrate away	✓	✗

Developer Experience

Feature	KnoxCall	AWS SM
Visual Dashboard Modern web UI for management	✓	~ AWS Console UX
Built-in Analytics Request metrics and insights	✓	✗ Requires CloudWatch setup
Real-time Geo Tracking See requests on a world map	✓	✗
Custom Alerts Email, SMS, Slack notifications	✓	~ Via CloudWatch Alarms

In Depth

AWS Secrets Manager is a solid choice if you’re fully committed to the AWS ecosystem. However, many teams find they need API proxying capabilities alongside secrets management—which means adding API Gateway and Lambda to the mix. KnoxCall provides both in a single, vendor-neutral platform.

The Multi-Service Challenge

To replicate KnoxCall’s functionality in AWS, you need Secrets Manager for credentials, API Gateway for routing, Lambda for transformation logic, CloudWatch for monitoring, and SNS for alerts. Each service has its own pricing, configuration, and learning curve. KnoxCall consolidates all of this into one platform with one bill.

Predictable vs Usage-Based Pricing

AWS’s per-call pricing can lead to surprising bills during traffic spikes. KnoxCall’s flat pricing means you always know what you’ll pay. Our Pro plan includes 1 million API calls for $99/month—achieving the same on AWS would cost significantly more when you factor in all the required services.

Multi-Cloud Freedom

If your architecture spans multiple clouds or you want to avoid vendor lock-in, KnoxCall works the same whether your backends are on AWS, GCP, Azure, or your own data center. AWS Secrets Manager is designed exclusively for AWS workloads.

For teams that need a complete API security solution without AWS lock-in, KnoxCall offers a simpler path. Get API proxying, secrets management, analytics, and alerts in one platform—without assembling multiple AWS services.

Pricing Comparison

KnoxCall

Starter$19/mo

2 Secrets
10K API calls/month
Basic Analytics
All included

Pro$99/mo

25 Secrets
1M API calls/month
Advanced Analytics
Static IPs
All included

Enterprise$299/mo

Unlimited Secrets
Unlimited API calls
Priority Support
All features

AWS Secrets Manager

Per Secret$0.40/secret/mo

Per secret stored
Minimum 1 cent/month
4-hour min charge on delete

API Calls$0.05/10K calls

Per 10,000 API calls
Adds up quickly
Plus Lambda/API GW costs

AWS pricing can become expensive and unpredictable. 25 secrets + 1M API calls = ~$15/mo for secrets + $5 for calls, plus additional Lambda and API Gateway costs if you need proxying.